The State to Indemnify a Lender Misled by a Forged Land Registration Certificate of Title
Introduction
In a recent judgment, the High Court sitting in Nairobi Milimani Commercial Courts has held that the State must indemnify a lender that lent money to a client based on a fraudulently obtained land title. In Gulf African Bank v Halgan Megabids Limited & 7 others [2026] KEHC 12929 (KLR) the court held that under section 81 of the Land Registration Act, an error alone is enough to trigger indemnity. Further, it was held that no fraud or negligence by registry staff needed to be proved. Therefore, the Court entered judgment against the Ministry of Lands, the Chief Land Registrar and the Attorney General jointly and severally for Kshs. 102,369,273.50, with default interest at 20% per year. It also dismissed the claim for punitive and exemplary damages as there was no malice or recklessness on the State's role.
Brief Facts of the Case
Through a Letter of Offer dated 31st July 2019, Gulf African Bank advanced Halgan Megabids Limited a Kshs. 100 million Tawarruq facility. This loan was secured via legal charges over two properties namely, Limuru/Rironi/151 and Dagoretti/Kinoo/164, registered respectively in the names of the 5th and 4th Defendants. It was further secured by an all-assets debenture and personal guarantees from the company's directors. Later on the borrower defaulted with the Bank issuing statutory notices and moving in to realize the charged properties through auction.
During the realization stage, the Bank found out that there were irregularities in the title documents. Subsequently, the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) conducted investigations established that the titles had been fraudulently procured, and that signatures on the green card for one property had been forged. Therefore, the Bank sued the borrower, its directors and guarantors, and separately sued the Ministry of Lands, the Chief Land Registrar and the Attorney General. Default judgment was entered against the borrower and guarantors as they did not defend the suit. On the other hand, the State filed its defense, denying negligence or complicity and maintained that the registrations followed the ordinary statutory process.
Issue for Determination
Among the key issues for determination was whether the 6th and 8th Defendants were liable to compensate the Plaintiff for the outstanding or remaining loan amount.
Analysis
It was held that a registered title is indefeasible unless cases of fraud or illegalities proven against the holder. This decision was based on section 26(1) of the Land Registration Act that provides that a certificate of title is prima facie proof of absolute and indefeasible ownership. This can only be challenged when the holder of the certificate participated in fraud or misrepresentation, or acquired it illegally. It was established that the Bank relied on records issued by the Registry and was not at fault.
It was also held that an error in the Register makes the State liable to indemnify under Section 81(1) of the Land Registration Act that entitles a person who suffers loss through an error in the Register, or in an official search or extract, to compensation from the State. As this was a statutory claim rather than a frau claim, the Bank did not have to prove that the registry officials are complicit or negligent. Instead, it only needed to show the register was wrong and that it relied on it leading to a loss.
Conclusion and Implications
Judgment was entered for the Plaintiff against the 6th, 7th and 8th Defendants, jointly and severally, for Kshs. 102,369,273.50, with default damages at 20% per annum from 19th October 2021 until payment in full. Upon payment, the 6th to 8th Defendants are subrogated to the Plaintiff's rights against the 1st to 5th Defendants, up to the amount paid.
The implication of this decision is that it confirms that a clean search is not the same as a clean title. However, it still acts as a shield to the lender. It implies that a lender or bank that in good faith on an official search, valuation and Land Control Board consent is offered protections. This is the case even when the title or its certificate is later found to have been procured fraudulently or through forgery. It also shows that the State will inherit a lender’s claim against the defaulting borrower and guarantors once it remits payments.