Who Profits From Creative Works? Kenyan Courts Clarify Copyright Law

Who Profits From Creative Works? Kenyan Courts Clarify Copyright Law

🎧 Listen to this article

Introduction

In a recent decision, the High Court of Kenya has clarified who must confirm rights before creative work becomes profitable. In Kimani v Safaricom Ltd & 2 others; Music Copyright Society of Kenya & another (Third party) [2023] KEHC 20085 (KLR), an artist known as Mr. Bamboo lodged a complaint that three of his songs were sold as caller ringback tones on Skiza Tunes in the period between 2009 and 2014. Safaricom Ltd had obtained them from two content providers that relied on a copyright society and a licensing company.

However, in a decision by Justice A. N. Ongeri, the three Defendants were found to be liable, with the Court reasoning that they failed to exercise due diligence when using the copyright owner’s creative works. It was established that having exploited the songs, they could not point fingers upstream, as it was their duty to confirm that the artist had assigned his rights to the songs. The High Court also held that the unauthorized use of his creative works or songs had left the artist at the mercy of three parties who had not participated in creating the works. As none of the three Defendants produced the record of their earnings from using the Plaintiff’s copyrighted songs, the Court assessed damages at a figure of Kshs. 1,500,000.00 for each song totaling to Kshs. 4,500,000.00, jointly and severally against the Defendants. The Plaintiff was also at liberty to pursue the Third Parties for indemnity and a remedy against the suppliers.

Copyright Keeps a Stricter Rule

The import of the above decision is that copyright maintains a stricter rule in protecting the rights of the creator of the works. Accordingly, Section 33 of the Copyright Act, 2001 requires a user to obtain an assignment, and any exclusive licence must be written and signed by or for the grantor. On the other hand, non‑exclusive licences may be obtained orally or inferred from the conduct of parties.

It means that a user who commercially exploits a work must at all times verify the chain of title before use rather than after the complaint. Under this, liability will be tested at every level within this chain.

Therefore, the rationale for finding the Defendants liable was on the basis that the use of the Plaintiff’s music was an infringement on his intellectual property rights. The result is that his copyright to the music was rendered valueless and he never benefited from it.

Conclusion and Practical Implications

This decision confirmed that copyright owners must be allowed to enjoy the profits of their creative works. In essence, the decision reaffirmed that telecommunication operators, platforms and distributors must obtain and keep the executed assignment or licences from artists before using their works. Moreover, a supplier’s warranty, indemnity or a collecting society’s confirmation of membership does not protect a party against the intellectual property owner. The upshot is that parties must at all times obtain the permission of the copyright owner before exploiting their works for commercial gains.

Related Articles

Ready to Talk?

Get In Touch