Landmark KShs. 157 Million Damages Bill for Medical Negligence: Essential Lessons for Medical Practitioners and Healthcare Providers in Kenya

Landmark KShs. 157 Million Damages Bill for Medical Negligence: Essential Lessons for Medical Practitioners and Healthcare Providers in Kenya

🎧 Listen to this article

Introduction

The High Court of Kenya sitting at Nairobi delivered a landmark decision in June 2025 awarding a woman KShs 157 million for medical negligence during a procedure performed by a medical professional at one of the most renowned healthcare providers in the country. In Naila Qureshi & Another vs Dr. Raffique Parker & 2 others, Case Number CC 610 OF 2007, the Court awarded Naila Qureshi and her husband KShs 157 million after the doctor and the hospital who operated on her were found guilty of medical negligence, failure to obtain informed consent, and lack of institutional accountability on the part of the employing healthcare provider.

Brief Facts of the Case

In September 2006, Naila Qureshi (the Plaintiff) underwent surgery at Aga Khan University Hospital (the 3rd Defendant) for pelvic endometriosis. However, without her informed consent, Dr. Rafique Parker (the 1st Defendant) removed her cervix and also scarred her bladder, causing her to develop a fistula. These actions by the 1st Defendant caused the Plaintiff to suffer severe physical and psychological harm, while she also used Kshs. 7,200,000.00 for treatment in Kenya and abroad.

Despite the Plaintiff’s complaints of the pain and challenges in participating in normal bodily functions, the 1st Defendant assured her of her well-being and future healing. The medical negligence was discovered during a visit to South Africa, after which the Plaintiff sued the 1st Defendant and Aga Khan Hospital, where he was engaged as a medical practitioner.

Decision

It was held that the 1st Defendant was guilty of medical negligence while performing its functions as a urologist. The 3rd Defendant was also found liable for corporate negligence as it failed to vet the 1st Defendant to ascertain his professional qualifications or standing. As such, the Plaintiffs were awarded Kshs. 157 million in damages, holding both the doctor and the hospital liable.

Rationale

The Court’s reasoning was based on the failure by the 1st Defendant and the 3rd Defendant to uphold the duty of care, amongst other reasons. First, the Court applied the modified objective test articulated in Arndt v. Smith [1977], which requires medical practitioners to offer patient-specific information about the risks and alternatives during a medical procedure.

The 1st Defendant’s consent form was not signed and failed to demonstrate that he informed the 1st Plaintiff of the removal of the cervix, which violated the standards set in Montgomery v. Lanarkshire Health Board [2015].

Further, the 1st Defendant’s negligence was demonstrated by the 2006 procedure, when he performed a bladder surgery without the urological expertise, which eventually caused the fistula. The Court relied on expert witness reports that informed it that the absence of a multidisciplinary approach breached the standards set out in Huck’s v. Cole [1968].

On the other hand, the hospital’s liability arose from corporate negligence in failing to vet the 1st Defendant, who was banned from practicing in Uganda for previous medical misconduct. Its liability also arose from failing to provide advanced diagnostic tools and the delayed detection of the fistula condition. The Court also placed emphasis on the hospital’s non-delegable duty to ensure that it engages competent practitioners and provides adequate facilities, as was articulated in Darling v. Charleston Community Memorial Hospital [1965].

The Court also justified the substantial damages for physical, emotional, and financial harm caused to the Plaintiffs by relying on the decision in Tayab v. Kinanu [1983].

Conclusion and Implications

This decision reinforces the need for patient safety and trust in medical practitioners and healthcare providers. Practitioners and providers must act decisively by obtaining informed consent before procedures. They must also verify and vet the qualifications of providers while at the same time being transparent and accountable in their engagements with patients. This judgment underscores the need for practitioners and providers to maintain legal and ethical standards to strengthen patient safety. Without compliance with this, it may lead to costly medical negligence cases to their detriment.

Related Articles

Ready to Talk?

Get In Touch