Medical Negligence in Kenya: Lessons for Medical Practitioners, Healthcare Institutions and Patients

Medical Negligence in Kenya: Lessons for Medical Practitioners, Healthcare Institutions and Patients

🎧 Listen to this article

Introduction

Kenyan Courts have recently held medical professionals and healthcare institutions liable for medical negligence. In the case of Amisi v Siaya County Referral Hospital & Another (Civil Suit 5 of 2019) [2022] KEHC 12117 (KLR) (17 August, 2022), the High Court offered a timely reminder to medical personnel and hospitals the required standard of care and the repercussions that follow when they fall short of it by their acts and omissions.

Brief Facts of the Case

Elizabeth Ambale Amisi underwent a Caesarean section at Siaya County Referral Hospital, during which she successfully delivered her baby and was subsequently discharged. However, a few days after, she began experiencing abdominal pain accompanied with swelling. She returned to the same hospital where an ultrasound examination revealed that cotton wool and a surgical blade had been left in her abdomen during the initial operation. Consequently, she underwent a second surgical procedure to remove the surgical materials and instrument. Elizabeth testified that since the second surgery, she was still in pain and she had subsequently not been able to have children leading to breaking down of her marriage.

Decision

The Court identified the following issues for determination:

  1. Whether the Defendants owed the Plaintiff a duty of care
  2. Whether the Defendants breached that duty
  3. Whether the Plaintiff suffered any damage or loss as a result of the breach of that duty
  4. Whether the Plaintiff was entitled to damages and if so, the quantum

In determining whether the Defendants owed the Plaintiff a duty of care, the Court emphasized that a duty of care arises once a doctor or other health care professional agrees to diagnose or treat a patient. That professional assumes a duty of care towards that patient. It therefore followed that a duty of care arose once the Hospital and the medical personnel agreed to admit, diagnose and treat the Plaintiff.

On whether the Defendants breached their duty of care, the Court held that the Defendants breached their duty of care to the Plaintiff. The Court relied on the Plaintiff’s witness Dr Thaddeus Owiti, who concluded from examination of discharge summary presented to him by the Plaintiff, that the cause of the Plaintiff’s pain was a foreign object that was left in her abdomen, necessitating the second surgery. Additionally, the Court noted that despite the Defendants alleging that the ultrasound carried out on the Plaintiff prior to the second surgery revealed no foreign objects, the Defendants failed to produce in evidence the said ultrasound or even the sonographer’s report to demonstrate that no foreign object was seen or found in the Plaintiff’s abdomen following the second surgery.

The Court emphasized that medical practitioners are required to exercise the degree of care, diligence and skill reasonably expected of a competent medical professional within the same field, acting under similar circumstances. The Court further noted that medical negligence arises where a doctor or other healthcare professional fails to provide the appropriate standard of care in the treatment of a patient, thereby causing injury, harm or in severe cases, death.

In determining whether the Plaintiff suffered loss as a result of the breach of the duty of care, it was the Court’s finding that the second surgery undertaken by the Defendant on the Plaintiff was necessitated by the pain that the Plaintiff had undergone following the infection caused by negligence on the part of the doctors who operated on her the first time. Further, the inability of the Plaintiff to get any children since she last had surgery was not controverted, and corroborated her testimony that she suffered pain as a result of the second surgery.

In awarding the Plaintiff damages, the Court borrowed what the Supreme Court of India observed in the case of IMA v V.P. Shanta and Ors III (1995) CPJ I (SC) as follows:

“A patient who has been injured by an act of medical negligence has suffered in a way which is recognized by the law and by the public at large as deserving compensation. This loss is continuing and what may seem like an unduly large award may be little more than that sum which is required to compensate him for such matters as loss of future earnings and the future cost of medical or nursing care. To deny a legitimate claim or to restrict arbitrarily the size of an award would amount to substantial injustice. After all, there is no difference in legal theory between the Plaintiff injured through medical negligence and the Plaintiff injured in an industrial or motor accident.”

Accordingly, the Plaintiff was awarded Kshs. 4,000,000 in general damages for pain and suffering and Kshs. 8,205.00 awarded as special damages.

Conclusion and Implications

The significance of this decision is that medical practitioners and hospitals are required not only to offer care to the required standards but also maintain clear and complete records of the professional qualifications of their staff. This includes proper handover and documentation of the procedures they administer to their patients. Every piece of evidence matters in the entire process and gaps in them can greatly shift the burden of proof.

Hospitals also bear a legal duty of care similar to that imposed on the medical personnel they employ. Accordingly, a hospital may be held vicariously liable for negligent acts or omissions committed by its employed in the course of providing medical care, just as any employer may be held liable for the negligence of employees acting in the performance of their assigned duties.

Related Articles

Ready to Talk?

Get In Touch